Sort of what Julia Childs used to say, I think. The low-carb group lost significantly more weight and had greater improvements in blood triglycerides and HDL cholesterol. Sondike SB, et al. At least 11 players for the Tennessee Titans football team fresh off their first playoff victory in 15 years are following a primarily plant-based diet. The low-carb diet caused significantly more weight loss and reduced hunger compared to the low-fat diet. So, back to the original question, does this sound like a GAPS type situation to you? When I woke up yesterday, I ate a bowl full of sliced apples and blueberries with some decaf coffee and raw milk.
Featured in Health
Some people thrive on meat only. To each his own! Although I have added back grains rice , I keep a close eye on my portions, as I have a family history of diabetes and also had gestational diabetes while prego with my three kids.
Thanks so much for this article! Thanks to you I found Matt Stone a few weeks back. The worse I felt, the less carbs I ate…thinking this would help. And guess what…I felt better! I think it also helped that for the 1st time in forever I was able to spend 10 minutes making, eating and cleaning up from breakfast instead of the normal 30 minutes for eggs, sausage, etc.
Therefore I was able to actually leave for work on time without being totally stressed out. As the co-owner of a small business with my wife , father of a month old daughter and soon-to-be father of a son, I have better things to do with my life and energy than stress about whether or not Caveman Carl would permit me eating a pizza and drinking a beer not her with my wife on a Friday night.
Thanks again and preach on! Thanks for your posting on this. I too fair a lot better when I increase my carbs. I am 49 and very athletic. I found paleo late and decided for the next year to beat myself over the head with that stick.
I actually got worse, was having sub clinical hypo symptoms and AF putting on weight and feeling worse. My theory, its fine for a lot of younger women that havent had their hormones screwed up for one reason or another, but us older and hormonally fragile women, we need to tread carefully.
I am still a bit wary of carbs but I do eat more ie gms or so a day without a problem and feel so much better. My reverse T3 kicked up about 18 months ago, so I am on a low dose of T3, which tbh, isnt doing enough BUT most of the time my basal body temp is above 98 since I started taking it and lately during ovulation and the last half of my cycle I will see I still have a lot of damage, I have no control over my body comp, I used to have a lot of muscle definition till about 3 years ago, and even though I do my intervals and practice vigorous yoga I can no longer influence that to any degree.
If I over eat just a tiny bit, I will gain weight no problem. My sleep is way better now and I think that is because I eat more carbs. I doubled my caloric intake in October. Some, but not a lot. Since I upped the carbs in Jan, the temps have really come up and my period is starting to regulate. Which leads me to robert what the role of contraceptives might be in all of this — an artificially induced state of elevated sex hormones that could disguise the harmful effects of VLC diets….
Well, I can say this much. Several years ago, I went low carb and lost 30 lbs. I eventually got tired of the diet and was missing my carbs so, I added them back in. I slowly gained the weight back. Fasting is ONLY for healthy people. So, I fear that going low carb and IF caused my adrenals and thyroid to fare even worse. I also was tired a lot. I did eat lots of honey and fruit but was still on the couch every day with fatigue.
Fast forward again, and I thought I would attempt a Whole I made it to 14 days before cracking and adding back in raw dairy only to feel immediately better, only to follow that with grains again. Everyday on the Whole30 I felt completely drained, tired and starving!
I was eating and thinking about food all. And I was eating lots of fruit and sweet potatoes. This past summer I thought, screw it! I had more energy and was exercising even! Despite exercising and feeling great, I still gained a little weight over the summer.
Over analyzing what we eat, depriving ourselves, not enjoying our food, and denying cravings I believe is far worse for us. I can say, that I do feel so much better when at least eating potatoes, rice, sprouted corn tortillas, and sourdough bread.
I think people might think you are overdoing it with the carbs right now, but you are RRARFing, and that is meant to be done for only about 30 days. Also when you have been low carb for so long, your body is probably just trying to catch up.
People really need to focus less on their weights and more on their health. Our hormones are responsible for storing and releasing fat. Hot chocolate sounds good. And my nanny just went to the store to buy some tapioca for pudding. I could not agree more with this: I was going to mention that but forgot.
I did the same thing, paleo and I. F, twice a week for a month. I felt ok while I was doing it, it was easy in fact, but I know in retrospect it did some damage. I had been under stress for a couple of years, my adrenals were giving out and my thyroid was going under.
The guys that advocate I. I actually looked on line at the time to see if there were any contraindications about who shouldnt do it, and I didnt see any so I went ahead. In retrospect I should have known better. Both are paleo oriented, more so Brad, whom wrote a book about I. F without ONE mention about who should and shouldnt do it. I thought that was kind of irresponsible. I feel best on a traditonal foods broth, organs, ferments low-carb diet but I do provide potatoes, bananas, lentils, rice, and sprouted bread for my family.
I would like to eat higher carb but when I do I feel blah and get sick more. I am still very fertile with thick hair and have healthy babies eating this way. Price found, there is a wide range of ways to eat and be well in the traditonal foods context! A few days ago, I was sitting on the couch, trying to think of what to do for dinner.
I could barely move, I was so tired. I was freezing cold. An errand I really needed to do got me up and out the door.
I got some burgers and fries at In N Out and when I got home, I had a lot more energy and was able to put my kids to bed for the night. And my energy has been a lot better. Hopefully, my hair will stop falling out and I can regulate my temps pretty soon. Gosh I can SO relate to that! Interesting article — I have been going back and forth on the carbs issue too. I know, you write it and you can write what you want. I find them at Goodwill all the time for a buck! Still—yes, they eat fruit; yes, they eat tubers; NO, they do not have pancakes for breakfast every morning.
Michael Eades has an answer to your complaint about hair loss, if you were ever interested enough to look it up. Could be you have downregulated some enzyme past the point of no return. I became severely hypothyroid when I was eating lots of grains on a regular basis. I was starting to trend toward vegetarianism, so my soy consumption was up, but not horrifically so. I blame a lot of factors for my hypothyroidism, but low-carb is not one of them.
My hair is not falling out, nor is my sex drive in the toilet. My hair is growing lush and lustrous, my sex drive is high, and while my temp has not yet risen above I eat mostly Primally now, have lost a few pounds doing it, too, and I feel great!
Please understand, Ann Marie, that there is a big difference between grain-free and low-carb. If what you are doing works for you, then great! Heather Soy will absolutely cause hypothyroidism. Just getting off soy and stopping the vegetarian diet would very likely cause your hormones to improve. I blame years of stress and adrenal fatigue. Soy is just one piece of the puzzle.
I was diagnosed with PCOS. Was told by MD and naturopath the way to go was low carb. Did it, lost loads of weight… Problem fixed?? This coming from a total left brain here. Human beings are quite arrogant to think we do. At least the traditional cultures learned how to eat properly by trial and error never really knowing why. But we have lost most of that now. For me weight loss and sanity means restricted carbs: I do have fruit or some sweet potato a few times a week, but in very small portion.
But there is NO way I should be eating starch at every meal. Modern grains and gluten are just plain dangerous for many people and I know that includes me.
I have not read your comment yet — just squinting at it with eyes half closed because I can sense that it is nasty.
This sentence stands out at me like a flashing neon light: Do we remember what NICE means? He gained weight earlier like over a year ago recovering from a poor diet. Ack, how crazy is that?! We need to eat that way. In one study, rats put on rotation diets showed significantly less damage from lectins than rats fed soy proteins continuously.
Because the rats did nearly as well with the rotation diet as they did on a steady diet of high quality, low-lectin feed, the take away message is for us to eat a richly varied diet and to reduce repeated exposure to all lectinrich legumes, especially soybeans and kidney beans.
Did you read my post? Recently, I returned to the diet I was eating when I first found real food and Iconsciously added properly prepared grains and more pulses back into my diet and have seen my cycles regulate, my sleep improve and my waist-to-hip ratio improve.
My point is this: Most of the people whodo well on these diets are cutting out refined oils, refined grains and refined sugars. Those are the big ones. Most of the people who do well on these diets are cutting out refined oils, refined grains and refined sugars. Let alone trying to get a black and white nutritional program that works for every person everywhere.
There are guidelines, but no magic bullet. Which is a challenge for each of us to figure out what is best. Plus, the bottom line for me, more and more, is to live life, be happy, smile, enjoy my food, and live passionately. I got too dogmatic mostly in my head at the end of GAPS, but for the most part I was able to embrace it like a friend and take what was best from the diet.
But they are just food. We can be friends: This is really inspiring! I have also had many successes by adding more carbs to my diet.
Meeting Matt Stone changed my life! It helped my digestion get better and my nervous system to feel calmer, and my hands to feel warmer, but reading this makes me think perhaps I have not added enough carbs. My temp is still the same in the morning at I am going to up the carbs even more.
I gained weight, but am mostly not completely unconcerned about this; just want to heal the hormones! Thanks for this great post! Thank you so much for this post. Like you, I like Mark Sisson but I find it really difficult to be like him…especially as a 53 year old post-menopausal woman. PS — I had a baby at 40…and my friend had a baby at 43…it will happen!
So that sounds good to me! I like how you wrapped up your post with the comment from Jaminet. The bottom line is that everyone has to design a diet that suits their body the best. When you eat right for your body, you know it because you feel great.
Here is a great link for all of my fellow Weston A Price eerz. Reading comprehension has gone by the wayside, that is for sure! This post could be condensed as follows. Assess, by taking you temps to see if it helps. There was a big focus on grains and that was a big part of their diets. If everyone can learn to ditch the experts and listen to their bodies their health would improve. Everyone is different listen to your cravings and eat real, whole foods. That is all you need.
My husband is turning 50 this year and has gained unwanted weight around his middle over the last year or so. Maybe he could benefit from more carbs?
You can make a sweet sourdough recipe, that contains nutmeg for flavor. Then cut out the shapes you want. Bake after rising, then dip in butter right out of the oven then roll in a a mix of raw sugar and cin. I found this post very interesting. I tried everything I found to lose it, but nothing worked. I switched to dessicated thyroid and felt better still, but no change in my body. I lost almost 10 pounds the first month. I tried eating wheat bread traditionally prepared , and gained 2.
I went back to grain free and dropped it. I then experimented with rice again, traditionally prepared. Back to grain free the next week and my weight loss was back to my average just over a pound a week.
My blood work has improved a great deal, and my thyroid scores have finally stabilized whereas in the past I had to have a dosage increase annually. So, I was surprised that it had the opposite affect on you.
I think this really goes to show that you have to learn your own body and figure out what works for it, despite what may or may not work for others. I think this is exactly what my wife and I were experiencing. I am excited for you— I know people and family who have had children at 43 and 45 without any complications. I was excited to see your post! I know it works for some, not for me. I also remember having very low temperatures on these diets. There were many cultures that he studied that ate ample carbs and low protein.
And as we know, high protein diets can cause a whole host of problems with long-term effects. I also got pregnant on the first time and had no issue with milk supply, etc. Once I had my son, I boosted up my carbs even more and I not only lost all the weight within 9 months but am now thinner than I was before being pregnant. Glad someone like you, who has a lot of influence, is sharing this perspective. I also know that Dr. Again, I admire his willingness to be honest and change. I laughed so hard at that video you posted.
I even showed it to my nanny so she could try to understand me better. Of course, she is from Slovakia so she did not get most of the jokes. I remember going to my first WAPF chapter meeting. We had a hoot making it, and I love to make people laugh. And, sista, we have to laugh at ourselves, cuz some of this stuff is just crazy… crazy good, but still a little crazy: Ok, the Mercola stuff… yeah, very interesting… I knew there was some fishy things going on when he started doing all of these speaking engagements with Mr.
I remember reading that he is now down to eating meat only a few times a week. And hey, YAY for at home waterbirths!!! From one natural mama to another, I loved the issues you highlighted!! Not to say that stuff is nonsense?
Sometimes I get so overwhelmed with our culture of sarcasm that I get confused about the message, LOL. No way, that was you?? My sister showed me that recently as it reminded her of me, ha, and it is one of the most hilarious vids I have seen in a looong time! What caught my eye was the fat. Pre-ovulatory temps can be a full degree lower than postovulatory temps. The reason being that estrogen, early in our cycle lowers our temp slightly while the egg matures. Once the egg is released, the corpus luteum produces copious amounts of progesterone which warms our body for the possibility of conception think incubator.
If 5 or more temps throughout our cycle are below Great article by the way! My only criticism of this very enthusiastic post is the language used along with all that is low-carbing. You called it a fad and a bandwagon within two sentences! Where did it go?! Did it swing away on a fanatical pendulum and start taking coffee enemas with its friend Master Cleanse? Highly offensive and, dually, self-discrediting? Also eat dairy with no problem.
Weight loss has been slow but steady. I understand that it may seem like high everything, carbs,etc. I can go all day now — gardening, running errands, working, whatever — instead of feeling like I need to rest on the couch. I totally believe that you were hypothyroid back then. My musing is just that you took big doses of iodine without any sort of gradual adaptation, causing a hyperthyroid time, followed by a reactive hypo which is well documented phenomenon in the medical literature.
This probably coincided with the time that low carb started to suck for you. Low carb always sucked for me. This was according to labs not just my feeling. It does not help everyone. At the time, Dr. Cowan did not seem very positive in general about taking iodine. Please email me if you are interested in talking more about it. I just wanted to share my experience. We did GAPs a couple of years ago and life circumstances made it impossible to keep doing it. We were doing it for about 9 months.
Anyway, my oldest daughter has also always shown signs. I felt a lot better there, I am not sure if it was because it was so warm or what, but physically I felt better there. Anyway, we went on GAPS and all of our thyroid issues went away.
Well, not quite all, but close. Then we went off of GAPs and eating bread and pasta and such thyroid issues again, plus a lot of other health issues. So we are back on GAPs again, only been for about a month. Admittedly, we eat a lot of fat and meat, but I always make sure that there are peas, or carrots or squash in our foods.
I did that last time too. I much appreciated your post about GAPs myths. Now, some people maybe do feel better that way and that is fine. Again, there is no one diet for everyone. I am hoping that we will do GAPs better this time, mostly have some control over how we go off of it, by properly preparing our grains and starches.
I hope that will help. We will have to see. But I guess I just wanted to post that not low carb GAPs was working for us and has actually improved our thyroid issues even though I am sure our carbs have gone down from what we were eating. Well done Anne Marie. So I am the same — under the influence of Matt Almighty I have increased drastically my consumption of carbs and seen good results health wise.
The reliance on antibiotics and the loss of fermented food plus the pill for ladies certainly explain why our gut flora are in bad shape and why we now suffer from candida. GMO are gonna make it worse. However for having suffered from it myself it never made sense to me to link carbs and candida as carbs nourish ALL bacteria — good and bad. If you starve the bad guys by going low carb then you also starve the good ones. It can be called recovery and the only way to sustain such system is to be low carb all year long with the problem it brings.
Basically candida are watchmen in our blood; they are part of our bodies but will multiply and cause problem when blood sugar stay elevated for too long. But the real mind-blowing part is what follow: Even the good ones. So candida would not be an illness linked to too many carbs but to eating too much fat with the carbs! The more fat you eat with carbs, the longer blood sugar will stay elevated as they slow down the assimilation of glucose.
This is actually exactly why the WAPF folks recommend us to soak our carbs in fats and it might be very counterproductive! And to prove it I did their experiment — going all carbs for a few days starch and fruits only with almost no fat. My candida symptoms withdrew in 24 hours! If they reoccur I go lower on fat and it works every time.
The good folks of the WAPF do an incredible work but they also have personal views. They buy the link between insulin resistance and too much carbs, which is not proven and not a WAP theory. Sure enough traditional people were eating animals fats but not ALWAYS soaking their boiled sweet potatoes in sour cream, butter or bear fat.
Saturated fat from pastured animals is really healing…and it is essential for brain, heart, hormone, gut and joint health. Healed guts are essential to overcoming candida. And fat is excellent. Gabi why jumping on the opposite bandwagon?! This is certainly not my post neither my conclusion so please re-read. I have said that systematically eating carbs with a lot of fat might trigger the candida problem — not that we should not eat fat or acknowledge the low fat fad!
Frustrating to take this much time to explain other views and find it misunderstood. Nowhere did I say such things and certainly not in my post. I merely suggest that people suffering from candida can consider another theory and protocol that is to see if they feel better with their symptoms by not eating carbs with ton of fats all the time.
I was specifically commenting on your suggestion that fats combined with carbs was a problem…I can see my statements were unclear. But I absolutely promote individual study and decisions and I am sorry for causing offense. I guess some of my points were not clear enough. No worries, and I do appreciate your comments and your study…we all have much to learn…thankfully that can be fun!!
Then I conceived our fourth. I have more energy, more stable moods and simply look and feel better when I keep my carbs under about fifty grams a day. Cutting grains has been a lifesaver for all of us. Just watch out for problems cropping up. The tricky thing with low-carb is that for a lot of people it seems fabulous at first, all the benefits you mention.
And then the thyroid and adrenal issues begin…. Thanks for the post! What are your thoughts on knowing your metabolic type and then eating accordingly? I was low carb for quite some time, for over a year, more primal than paleo with raw milk in my diet. Before primal I was primarily, low- fat, vegetarian, high whole grains which were not soaked or sprouted. I have Low thyroid symptoms, just about all of them, temp hovers in the 96 range with the lows in Thyroid labs are normal except for low iodine and selenium.
Good luck with getting pregnant. I found it hugely enlightening. Hope your childbearing journey goes well!!! A few years back I went low-carb and ended up borderline hypoglycemic, with low blood pressure and a tendency to faint. I lost a lot of weight but I was cold and needed a lot of coffee to get through the day. Eventually the weight loss stalled and then started to come back. Then I made the huge mistake of starting birth control pills-before I knew anything about their danger or gut health-and have had two years of health problems since then.
I only took them for a few months but my eczema was out of control, and then I ended up on prednisone and antibiotics for skin infections. I tried going grain free and ended up sicker-I was in the hospital with a raging infection, which can be a side effect of going too low carb, according to an article I read by Jaminet. So last year, knowing that I wanted to conceive in the fall, I started focusing on eating a balanced diet, with properly prepared grains, lots of organic produce, and an emphasis on grass fed beef and wild seafood.
I did this even though I was overweight-i knew it was more important to get healthy than lose a little weight. Lots of eggs, leafy greens, and sweet potatoes, etc. And of course fermented veggies, beet kvass very healing after my time in the hospital and kombucha.
I also tracked my temps, which increased throughout the year, getting to about To me, it seems that you have to listen to your own body and prioritize what is the important goal for you-whether that is fertility, weight loss, or overall health.
Otherwise I will keep my sourdough starter busy! My pulse was 55! A lot of the low-carbers go into fits if you tell them you ate a baked pear. My circumstances are not your circumstances, and your circumstances are not their circumstances, ya know?
Most of the time, our bodies will let us know what they need or want, and we just have to learn to recognize the signs and signals. I too look forward to the GAPS post. Fruit seems to worsen my hypoglycemia and sugar cravings. I did have some properly prepared gluten free grains for a while prior to getting on the GAPS diet. I will be introducing more navy beans and lentils to try to bring up my carbs some after reading this. Look forward to seeing what other suggestions you have.
Sugar cravings can be helped with eating adequate protein and taking amino acids. Thanks for this post Annemarie. I tried the low carb thing and felt like death warmed over. Low energy, crappy sleep, grumpy. Low carb seems to be everywhere now. If it werent for you I may not have found my way out. Thanks for being so brave and telling like it is, and not worrying about the carb police.
And for just being effing you. Why all the focus on grains? I do agree that a higher carb diet may be optimal in the long run.
In fact he says they are fattening. Why do you choose to eat grains? Eat tons of veggies, medium prtotein and lots of fat. Buy the best rEal food possible — eat raw veggies daily with meals, throw in some probiotic foods and eat grains sparingly as well as dairy — a bit more dairy if totally grass fed.
A semi-paleo diet has always worked really for me when I needed to lose weight after having each of my babies. It was working for me this time too. I have been struggling to lose the last eight pounds for the last year.
Many years ago I tracked my basal body temp when I was trying to conceive, and it was definitely low. I was already suspecting low-thyroid to be at least part of the problem.
I made muffins yesterday and ate three. It was scary, but I did it: Gayle I can relate! I was down to eating like 1, calories a day — and even then, the pounds would not budge. I am so sorry going low-carb caused so much issues.
For me it was the opposite. I am 24 and last year was the first time I had any signs of ovulation and that was after 5 months on primal. My Basal temperature when I am close to my period gets anywhere from I also go to the extreme, before I ovulate I eat less than 30g of carbs a day and go heavy on fat and meat and you know what? It comes down to this. Each person is different and unique. I had to go this route because I am allergic to all grains and have digestive issues from years of childhood antibiotics and medications and poor food choices.
A good portion of primal people do dairy and a variety of sweeteners not approved for Paleo, just thought I would add that for the curious ones. The whole low carb, high carb thing is so inorganic to me. Celiac disease actually was increasing. Indeed, the research confirms estimates that about 1 percent of U. That translates to about 1. On the flip side, about 1. Celiac disease is a condition that damages the lining of the small intestine when a person eats gluten found in wheat, barley, rye or some oats, preventing the intestine from absorbing necessary nutrients.
A strict gluten-free diet is often prescribed for people with the disease. Fads aside, the new study suggests more people are truly getting sick from the gluten found in wheat, rye and barley, but the reasons aren't clear. In the most serious cases, gluten triggers celiac disease, which can cause symptoms including abdominal pain, bloating and intermittent diarrhea. The lack of nutrients can cause sufferers to experience weight loss, fatigue, rashes and other problems.
Celiac disease is different from an allergy to wheat, which affects a much smaller number of people, mostly children who outgrow it. It was once considered extremely rare in the U.
But about 20 years ago, a few scientists began exploring why celiac disease was less common here than in Europe and other countries. They concluded that it wasn't less common here; it was just under-diagnosed. Scientists suggest that there may be more celiac disease today because people eat more processed wheat products like pastas and baked goods than in decades past, and those items use types of wheat that have a higher gluten content.
Gluten helps dough rise and gives baked goods structure and texture. In the s, scientists began cross-breeding wheat to make hardier, shorter and better-growing plants. It was the basis of the Green Revolution that boosted wheat harvests worldwide. Norman Borlaug, the U. But the gluten in wheat may have somehow become even more troublesome for many people, Murray said. That also may have contributed to what is now called "gluten sensitivity.
Doctors recently developed an ambiguous definition for gluten sensitivity. It's a label for people who suffer bloating and other celiac symptoms and seem to be helped by avoiding gluten, but don't actually have celiac disease.
Celiac disease is diagnosed with blood testing, genetic testing, or biopsies of the small intestine. The case for gluten sensitivity was bolstered last year by a very small but often-cited Australian study.
Volunteers who had symptoms were put on a gluten-free diet or a regular diet for six weeks, and they weren't told which one. Those who didn't eat gluten had fewer problems with bloating, tiredness and irregular bowel movements. Clearly, "there are patients who are gluten-sensitive," said Dr. What is hotly debated is how many people have the problem, she added.
It's impossible to know "because the definition is nebulous," she said. One of the most widely cited estimates comes from Dr. Alessio Fasano, a University of Maryland researcher who led studies that changed the understanding of how common celiac disease is in the U. Fasano believes 6 percent of U. But that's based on a review of patients at his clinic - hardly a representative sample of the general public. Other estimates vary widely, he said. This cleanse promotes three smoothies, snacks, and water or detox tea each day for 10 days.
Smoothies are made from raw vegetables, like arugula, beet greens, kale, parsley, and radish tops, along with fruits. Side effects from following an extremely low-calorie diet even over a short period of time include fatigue, dizziness, and nausea. It's important to tell clients that the liver and kidneys don't need assistance in detoxification. If a client chooses to make green smoothies, stress that they can include them in a healthful, well-balanced eating plan. RDs should review the guidelines of each.
In addition, the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics provides reviews of a variety of fad diet plans at www. Further, the February release of the Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee report emphasized healthful eating patterns such as the Mediterranean, vegetarian, and Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension diets.
These eating patterns have been gaining recognition in the general population and may be some of the plans clients choose.
As RDs, it's important to work with people to help them lose weight. However, the safety and nutritional profile of a plan should be of utmost concern so clients can lose weight, keep it off, and remain healthy.
She's also a nutrition expert for FoodNetwork. January Issue Ask the Expert: Great Valley Publishing Company, Inc.